Not all PTFE tape behaves the same. Generic material may work, but fidget-specific PTFE tape is better when it has been chosen and tested with slider feel, sound, and fitment in mind. That is the difference between random tape and a setup made for the hobby.
Final thoughts
A careful PTFE application can make a big difference in how a slider feels and wears over time. If you are looking for fidget-specific PTFE tape made for slider use, check out TEFMAX Ultra by PLAYFORBEANS.